Rush guitarist Alex Lifeson’s band announce their second album • Blu-ray exclusive to SDE • Quick pre-order
And now for something completely different. After a recent run of albums by legendary artists (Elton John, The Who, Simple Minds etc.) the SDE Surround Series takes a break from the big name reissues and ventures into less familiar waters for a very exciting new studio album from Envy of None, the new-ish Canadian-American ‘supergroup’ formed by Rush guitarist Alex Lifeson, along with bassist Andy Curran, vocalist Maiah Wynne, and guitarist and keyboardist Alfio Annibalini. The album in question is called Stygian Waves and is their second record following the band’s self-titled debut in 2022.
Why have I chosen to do this? The answer lies in the strength of the music, because the album is truly fantastic and I think you’ll love it! Recorded primarily in Toronto in 2024 and entirely self-produced, Stygian Waves is a moreish delight which combines electronic/synth textures with melodic rock, an occasional sprinkling of eastern influences and the superb breathy vocals of Maiah Wynne. The detailed production is absolutely brilliant (some aspects reminded me of Garbage at their best) and it sounds even better in immersive Dolby Atmos!
The 11-track album includes the epic ‘The Story’, the powerful widescreen pop-rock of ‘Under The Stars’, the insistent and catchy-as-hell ‘Thrill of the Chase’ (which includes a cheeky musical nod to The Beatles’ ‘Day Tripper’) , the yearning ‘Handle With Care’ and the dreamy, hypnotic ‘Raindrops’ with its choppy guitars and delicious keyboard sequences. The two songs that have been made available so far are opener ‘Not Dead Yet’ and ‘That Was Then’. You can preview both songs on this post.
If you’d like to know more about the band, obviously Envy of None marked the first full-band project from guitarist Alex Lifeson since his groundbreaking work with the legendary prog-rock trio Rush. Andy Curran (bass, programming, guitar) was in Canadian hard rock band Coney Hatch (they released three albums in the 80s) and Alfio Annibalini (guitar, keyboards) is also a producer and mixed Stygian Waves. Lead vocalist Maiah Wynne is arguably the star of the album which also features Randy Cooke on drums.
The SDE exclusive blu-ray of Stygian Waves features the album in the following audio streams:
Dolby Atmos (48/24)
5.1 Surround (48/24)
Hi-res stereo (96/24)
Additionally, it includes four promo videos in HD:
That Was Then (Video) [03:46]
Not Dead Yet (Video) [03:29]
Under The Stars (Video) [04:32]
Stygian Waves (Video) [03:37]
The Dolby Atmos Mix and 5.1 mixes were created by Alex Gamble and mastered by Justin Gray at Immersive Mastering.
Envy of None. From left to right Alex Lifeson, Maiah Wynne, Alfio Annibalini & Andy Curran
If you love grown-up rock/pop with and edge, full of great tunes and a brilliant layered production, I think you will really enjoy this album. And of course this unique [region-free] SDE blu-ray is a brilliant way to showcase the sound with its immersive Atmos Mix, the 5.1 surround version and hi-res stereo. Not forgetting the visual delights of those videos.
It is available to pre-order from today, direct from the SDE shop using this link or the buttons below, but be aware that this will be limited to just 1,000 units. Stygian Waves is #35 in the SDE Surround Series and comes in the usual clear amaray case packaging, shipping with a free and collectible SDE slipcase.
The album is released on 28 March 2025 (was 14 March), via Kscope. A limited edition blue vinyl edition is also available.
Tracklisting
Stygian WavesEnvy of None/SDE exclusive blu-ray audio
Stygian Waves is featured on the blu-ray in the following audio streams: Dolby Atmos Mix, 5.1 Surround (48/24) and Stereo (96/24)
Not Dead Yet [03:29]
The Story [04:41]
Under The Stars [04:32]
Thrill Of The Chase [03:40]
Handle With Care [04:14]
That Was Then [03:46]
Raindrops [03:33]
New Trip [03:55]
Clouds [04:02]
The End [03:58]
Stygian Waves [03:37]
HD Promo Videos
That Was Then (Video) [03:46]
Not Dead Yet (Video) [03:29]
Under The Stars (Video) [04:32]
Stygian Waves (Video) [03:37]
1 Tears For Fears / The Tipping Point
2 xPropaganda / The Heart is Strange
3 Gilbert O’Sullivan / Driven
4 Shakespears Sister / Hormonally Yours
5 Brian Eno / ForeverAndEverNoMore
6. Orbital / Optical Delusion
6.5 Various Artists / Concert For George
7 Ten Years After / A Space in Time
8 Bob Dylan / Time Out Of Mind (2022 Remix)
9 Tears For Fears / The Hurting
10 Mike Oldfield / Tubular Bells
11 Suede
12 ABC / The Lexicon of Love
13 Duran Duran / Danse Macabre
13a Duran Duran / Danse Macabre De Luxe
14 Trevor Horn / Echoes – Ancient and Modern
15 Soft Cell / Non-Stop Erotic Cabaret
16 Def Leppard / Diamond Star Halos
17 Paul Young / No Parlez
18 Mark Knopfler / One Deep River
19 Wham! / Fantastic
20 Wham! / Make It Big
21 Keane / Hopes and Fears
22 Luther Vandross / Never Too Much
23 Crowded House / Gravity Stairs
24 Ultravox / Lament
25 Tori Amos / Unrepentant Geraldines
26 Bronski Beat / The Age of Consent
27 Thin Lizzy / 1976: Jailbreak and Johnny The Fox
World Party – the near one-man-band from the much missed Karl Wallinger – issued a greatest hits called Best in Show back in 2007, to coincide with US and Australian tours. The compilation was never released outside of those territories but that is soon to be corrected with an expanded reissue that also sees Best in Show issued on vinyl for the first time.
When Karl spoke to SDE back in 2012, we discussed Best in Show. He said: “Well I was told, ‘you gotta have a greatest hits, buddy’. So I rang someone up and asked them for the iTunes figures for downloads that week, and the running order is based entirely on that list! [laughs]. Just put it on there and stick it out. Because I hate all those things, I don’t know why.”
That reasoning is why the compilation was always so Goodbye Jumbo heavy, although the four bonus tracks added to the 2025 reissue offer some balance. They are ‘Everybody’s Falling In Love’ (an at the time new-ish song from 2012’s Arkeology, and so its first time on vinyl), ‘Best Place I’ve Ever Been‘ (from the last studio album, 2002’s Dumbing Up), ‘Always’ from Egyptology (1997) and Sunshine from 1993’s Bang!
First time on vinyl for Best in Show
Karl’s manager confirmed to SDE that the audio has been remastered by Tim Young of Metropolis and the artwork has been enhanced by Richard Evans (of Hipgnosis fame).
To reiterate, this compilation has never been issued at all in in the UK and Europe and this is now the vinyl debut everywhere for Best in Show, which is pressed as a 2LP set on red and yellow vinyl for this reissue.
SDE is pleased to support this release and is selling the vinyl, CD and a bundle from the SDE shop. Best in Show will be released on 14 March 2025 via Seaview Records (initially announced as 14 Feb).
Climie Fisher’s debut album Everything will be reissued as a 5CD box set, in March.
The British pop duo consisted of vocalist Simon Climie and former keyboardist Rob Fisher. Climie was a musician and songwriter who at the time was best know for co-writing the George Michael and Aretha Franklin number one ‘I Knew You Were Waiting (For Me)’ while Rob Fisher (who sadly died in 1999) had enjoyed success in the early 80s as one half of new wave duo Naked Eyes, who racked up a couple of big US hit singles from their first album.
Everything was released in 1988 and is best remembered for the hits ‘Rise to the Occasion’ and ‘Love Changes Everything’, the latter of which initially flopped in the UK, then hit No 2 when it was re-released. Five tracks on the album were produced by Steve Lillywhite while six were produced by Stephen Hague (although for the Hip Hop Mix of ‘Rise to the Occasion’ Hague’s original production gets “additional production and remix” from Phil Harding).
The 5CD of Everything (click image to enlarge)
The 5CD box set is incredibly comprehensive, including as it does numerous single versions, B-sides, edits, alternate versions, extended mixes and a massive 25 previously unreleased recordings (including a load of dub mixes and extended versions).
All tracks have been remastered (using the original master tapes) and the box comes with a 28-page booklet with lyrics, discography, rare photos, and more.
The Everything 5CD box will be released on 21 March 2025, via Cherry Red.
The Who’s classic 1971 album Who’s Next – “arguably their artistic pinnacle” in the words of Alexis Petridis – is released as an SDE-exclusive standalone blu-ray audio, this week. Features the Atmos, 5.1 and hi-res stereo of album and bonus tracks. Plus exclusive instrumentals. This has SOLD OUT on pre-order.
Next month, Now That’s What I Call Music will release a genre-spanning ‘Era’ release called The Sound of the Suburbs 1977-1980.
In 4CD form, this set offers 80 tracks encompassing punk, new wave, reggae, ska, mod, post-punk and electronic. They were all initially released between 1977 and the end of 1980, and artists include The Undertones, The Clash, Elvis Costello, The Boomtown Rats, The Jam, The Cure, The Police, Rezillos, The Specials, The Beat, Japan, Jonathan Richman & The Modern Lovers, PIL, Devo, Skids, The Vibrators, XTC, John Foxx, The B-52s and many more.
Deluxe 4CD version of The Sound of the Suburbs
This comes in Yearbook style packaging options, so that means a deluxe hardcover book4CDversion (with 28-page booklet), a 3LP edition (51 tracks on black, white and red coloured vinyl) and a budget-conscious standard 4CD set in a card sleeve.
Full tracklistings for the formats are listed below. Whether this ‘Era’ release is the start of a new series or a one-off remains to be seen.
NOW That’s What I Call An Era: The Sound Of The Suburbs 1977-1980 will be released on 7 February 2025.
Compare prices and pre-order
Various Artists
the sound of the suburbs - 4CD deluxe in casebound book
Steven Wilson will release his eighth studio album, The Overview, in March.
The two-track, 42-minute album is inspired by the “overview effect” experienced by astronauts looking back at the Earth from space and sees Wilson return to expansive, progressive music, a genre he helped redefine and repopularise with both his solo and Porcupine Tree releases.
The two lengthy, ambitious tracks are each made up of distinctive musical sections that flow from one to the other, playing out as unique and continuous pieces incorporating everything from glistening electronics to post-rock and beyond. The album also features a set of lyrics by XTC’s Andy Partridge that help drive the story in ‘Objects Outlive Us.
SDE was lucky enough to hear the whole album in Dolby Atmos last November at a special preview event in North London and it sounded ambitious and very impressive.
Steven Wilson and SDE Editor Paul Sinclair at The Overview preview
In terms of formats, the album is available on CD, standalone blu-ray (with Atmos, 5.1, hi-res stereo and instrumentals), various coloured vinyl (the pick of which is probably the mint green version) and as a 2CD+blu-ray deluxe edition (in 96-page book packaging) which offers a bonus CD featuring 60 minutes of music (called The Alterview) not included on the final album and an specially commissioned orchestral version of the 23 minute long ‘Objects Outlive Us’ (called ‘Orchestral Objects’). The blu-ray in the deluxe is different to the standalone version since it adds The Alterview in hi-res stereo (only) and ‘Orchestral Objects’ in 5.1 and Atmos.
Late last year, BMG reissued the Thompson Twins‘ classic 1984 album, Into The Gap, as a 40th anniversary reissue as a 3CD set, on red vinyl and of course on SDE exclusive blu-ray audio. Last month, I caught up with Tom Bailey and Alannah Currie (separately) to discuss the album and the reissue. Between them they discuss working with producer Alex Sadkin, the fun (and pressure) of being a pop star in the early 1980s, life on the road, writing and recording the album and more…
SDE: What were your feelings when BMG approached you with regards to the Into The Gap reissue? I know in the past – I’m thinking of the Demon Music reissues in 2008 – that perhaps there’s been a bit of reluctance to engage. What’s changed all these years later?
Tom Bailey: I’m trying to think back to the Demon release, but we were not really active. We’re certainly not active as a band anymore. I hadn’t really got back into the live saddle at that stage [Tom only started playing Thompson Twins music again as a solo artist in 2014], so it was just something that was happening without our input, anyway. Record companies have always done that. I think there were several compilations, kind of greatest hits compilations, that we really had no say in – it just seemed like another one of those.
Alannah Currie: None of us got involved. We just let them [Demon] do whatever. Nothing to do with us. But for this [new reissue], we’ve talked to people. We’ve hauled out old photographs. We’ve helped them polish the jewels, really.
Tom: I think what happened was me getting back into playing live, and also the fuss about the 40th anniversary. Anticipating that, I tried to get this release out earlier in the year [2024], because I knew I was going on tour in America. That should have been a great moment to just promote the thing, but BMG, in their wisdom, were looking for a slot in their calendar where they could concentrate on doing a good job. That’s their call, they have to do what is right for them. But that’s what’s changed. Suddenly we’re in gear again, fighting for schedule synchronisation! [laughs]
SDE: 1984 always seemed like a classic year in pop music, where you had the likes of Duran Duran, Frankie Goes to Hollywood, Spandau Ballet, Culture Club and Wham! etc. and you were obviously a part of that. How did it feel to be in this movement that was happening. Did you feel part of that big surge of successful 80s pop bands?
Tom: I think so. Particularly with hindsight, there was a bit of a golden age thing going on there. At the time, it was very exciting, and it was great to have all that other stuff going on. There are golden ages in the 70s and 90s, so you can’t say that ours was the only one, but it started with The Human League’s early hits and ended, or partly ended with Frankie Goes to Hollywood, but definitely ended with Live Aid. That was the narrative arc of that golden age.
It was like the class of ’84, but we were the weirdos, we were the freaks
Alannah Currie
Alannah: We felt very much part of that scene. It was a bit like the class of ‘84, but we were the weirdos in the class. I think we were the freaks. We were slightly older than a lot of those others. We’d been round the block before. I think we were more political than a lot of them. We were into fashion and visuals and stuff, and we sort of had a vision of a new world, and we were sort of pushing to that. We were very much resisting writing love songs, or let’s-get-down-and-boogie songs, even though we love dance songs. I don’t know how much other bands were doing that. It’s very hard to look back now and judge where you were or how it worked. But we were definitely the freaks on the scene, but we really like being freaks. That was part of what we enjoyed about it – being slight outsiders.
SDE: This album, in particular, was the height of your commercial success. Did being a pop star match your expectations?
Tom: No. You can’t anticipate it or even understand it once it happened. But you can tolerate a certain amount of that as great fun. It’s like a party going on. And it’s interesting to discover that you become recognisable. Maybe I’m giving myself too much credit, but you have to keep these kind of things in some kind of perspective and once celebrity becomes more important than content, you’ve lost what you were doing. I think you can see that all around you at the moment. I’m so aware of a lot of people for how famous they are, but I’ve no idea what they actually do. That’s not entirely their fault, because that’s the way they’re marketed but it’s also the way that the scene has become fragmented. I don’t have time to listen to all of these famous young stars at the moment. However, back in the day, we’re talking in the early 80s, it was still the era of Top of the Pops, where everybody watched the same thing, and therefore the entire nation was aware of who the Thompson Twins were.
Once celebrity becomes more important than content, you’ve lost what you were doing
Tom Bailey
Alannah: It was shocking to get famous and to have that level of attention and enormity. And for a while it was really great fun. And I think the fun sort of ended after the Into The Gap album. Everything went downhill after that. So Into The Gap was the height of our fun days, if you like. When it was smaller, when you were still in contact with your friends, and it was still easy to come and go from your old life. That was a lot of fun. It was later on, when we became very isolated by having security and just working so much that we became very separate from the very things that inspired us, and then you end up writing songs about being on the road and that wasn’t fun. But at the beginning it was hilarious and really mad.
SDE: Do you think the fact that you were a little bit older than some of your contemporaries helped you deal with it a bit more maturely?
Alannah: In ‘84, I was 26. And Tom was 29, Joe was 31 or 32. But we’d had a lot of experience and we also came out of the squat scene. We did go off the rails, but that was later on.
Tom: I was probably a degree less stupid at 28 than I was at 18. Although sometimes stupidity amongst teenagers drives rock and roll forwards, because they don’t have the kind of control of their impulses with the old prefrontal cortex kicking in. Neurologists will tell us that that’s the reason. I don’t know. What the question really is, how do you handle the craziness, and is it easier to handle it if you’re a little bit older? And the answer is obviously yes, otherwise people don’t handle it and they crash land.
Stupidity amongst teenagers drives rock and roll forwards
Tom Bailey
SDE: Did you have a good relationship with Arista, your record company, in terms of their demands on you?
Tom: I think we did. There was a certain amount of advice to keep the American company at arm’s length because we were signed with the London-based branch of Arista, and we had a lot to do. I would go into the Arista office nearly every day to hang out, talk marketing ideas, artwork and so on, maybe pick up a few freebies. So it was a cool thing, whereas going into the office in New York was like, whoa, we have to play our cards right here. Otherwise we’ll end up having to do this, that or the other. And you know, to a certain extent that that turned out to be true. But we did have a good relationship with Arista, in London.
SDE: You’d already had a successful album with 1983’s Quick Step& Side Kick. Alex Sadkin had produced that album with you as well, of course. When you’d finished that record and you were starting to think about the next album, which would become Into The Gap, what was your game plan, what were your goals?
Tom: Interestingly, we were very goal and list oriented. We had band meetings discussing our manifesto, and how we’re going to achieve it; in order not to just drift aimlessly through the process. It’s very intense, so if you drift, you miss a lot of things. But right from the word go in the three-piece version of the Twins, we had a strict division of labour where we all got involved with writing, I did the music entirely. Alannah was writing lyrics. Joe was tossing ideas in. But fundamentally, the music was my side. Alannah was also working on the visual, the photography, the look, subsequently, the videos as well. Joe was thinking about designing the stage show, so we had three kind of separate areas, but when we actually went into recording Into The Gap, we thought let’s – more or less – follow the same plan to work with Alex: go to Compass Point first to cut the tracks and then bring it back to London to finish off in a mix. So that was the similarity. I think the difference was a couple of things. We weren’t quite so self-constraining with the instrumentation of Into The Gap. With Quick Step there was one guitar part on the whole album. We’d gone fully electronic. It was all synths and drum machines with a bit of percussion, maybe. However, suddenly on Into The Gap, guitars came back, pianos came back, so on and so forth – we broadened our instrumental palette. The other thing is, and this is more important, I think our songwriting had reached an emotional maturity where we were suddenly tackling bigger and deeper subjects. Quick Step is a great album, but it’s very heavy on the kind of quirky, eccentric side, rather than the heavier weight of emotions. There are no songs like ‘Hold Me Now’ or ‘Sister of Mercy’ on Quick Step.
We had band meetings discussing our manifesto, and how we’re going to achieve it
Tom Bailey
Alannah: With Quick Step & Side Kick we [originally] recorded the songs on a four-track in the front room. The first songs, they all came from storytelling between the three of us. I think the first thing we ever wrote was a track called ‘Kamikaze’ about how it must feel to be a suicide flyer. It was very beautiful and we were able to break it down. And it was fun. So we talked about that a lot, and then constructed it in the same way as we may have constructed a movie or a short film. I think a lot of Side Kick was like that. It wasn’t personal. None of that stuff was really personal. To us it was it was sharing and being excited by being in each other’s company and the threads of all the things we liked. Once we got to Into The Gap, and our second time working with Alex Sadkin – who was a brilliant producer, and who we loved working with – I think we relaxed a lot more. We had more confidence by then, and we were able to write a few personal songs. And weirdly, of course, the personal ones always become the huge hits, because that’s the unique thing that ties people together. It is love and death and glory.
SDE: Was it easy to get Alex Sadkin to work with you, on Quick Step & Side Kick?
Alannah: We were so naive. It was fantastic. I think we had four tracks on the demo tape for Side Kick. We sent off a tape, or the record company sent them to Alex in the Bahamas. At that point, I didn’t even know where the Bahamas was, I had been raised and brought up in New Zealand. I travelled a bit, but only directly to London where we were living in our squats. And suddenly we thought, oh, we really like this guy. We want to work with him. And then he said, come over in two weeks time and start recording. I remember walking off the plane in the Bahamas and we still had stinking leather jackets on. Of course, we’d chain smoked on the plane, probably the whole way there. We were just scruffy, smelly little brats, really. And there we were at Compass Point. It was amazing.
SDE: The key thing is you obviously had the confidence to go in and you weren’t overawed by the experience.
Alannah: If we were, we faked it. The whole thing about fame and that world is you have to have self-belief. As soon as your self-belief goes, you may as well just go. It’s like that with anything grand that you try in life. You have to have that self-belief and that confidence. We truly thought we were onto something; we thought we had written some great songs, and we had level of musicianship and a level of understanding of the world that we felt was good. Plus, we really liked each other, so the three of us together was really strong unit.
SDE: Was it all creatively driven? You weren’t thinking, “how are we going to have a bigger hit?“
Tom: I think we were, in the sense that we thought there’s no point in going into a studio until we know we’ve got at least four songs that do it for us, in the sense that we can imagine tapping our foot and singing along to it on a Saturday night. You can’t make the whole album like that otherwise it’s too constraining, so you just say what we need is four singles, they’re going to be hits, and then the rest of the album can be fun. We can explore all sorts of areas that we never expect to hear on Radio One or TopOf The Pops. We did do that, and once we realised that we had those four songs, which did indeed turn out to be the four singles, then we were happy to go in and start recording.
SDE: The songwriting credit on all the songs, it’s all three of you [Tom, Alannah and Joe Leeway]. Was that deliberate or is that just a fair reflection of how it was?
Tom: No, it doesn’t reflect the input in any way. But this is something that we’d established actually with the previous lineups of the Thompson Twins. Even in the seven piece, when we had a seven piece band, regardless of who wrote a song, I said we should divide this equally. There’s an advantage in that, which is that no one’s worried about getting paid and the subsequent effect of that is, if the writer takes all the publishing money, then other people are offering songs that maybe aren’t as good as the really good ones in order to get some money. It’s actually a quality control mechanism. Everyone’s going to get paid no matter what, let’s only have the best songs. Being paid equally means that we choose the best rather than, say, one of yours, one of hers, one of his…
SDE: Alannah, did you used to write lyrics on scraps of paper, or did you wait to hear some music and be inspired by it all?
Alannah: No, I always had notebooks. Funnily enough, I found something the other day, which was an old book where I’d been writing percussion parts. I didn’t know how to write music. I had my own sort of language for percussion parts, which was quite interesting. Like I said, often it just started with a story. We had a four-track, we had a small keyboard, and we had a little drum machine. This was right at the beginning and we’d just sort of record over and over and get tracks like that. Melodies would come in the early days from Tom, although they would be changed by Joe and sometimes changed by me. It was a real sort of three-way thing, but it always began with a sort of narrative, or Tom would have a melody that he wanted, that he thought was great with a beat, or Joe would come excited with something say, “My God, listen to this!” It was a real collaborative process. Tom, because his musicianship was much better, he was always given deference. But it was the same with me and all the visual stuff. People would input stuff, but it would be me that would make all the final decisions and work with whoever it was to make things happen
Alex Sadkin was up there with the with the greatest of the producers at the time
Tom Bailey
SDE: This is the second record you did with Alex Sadkin. Describe a little bit about what he was like as a producer and his impact on those two records that you made.
Tom: I’d say that Alex was up there with the with the greatest of the producers at the time. He really had a meticulous talent for getting projects through. Interestingly, he wasn’t really a musician. I think sometimes he would pick up a saxophone or something, and we would say “Put it down Alex, we’re not interested!”. He wasn’t really a musician, but what he was, was a sound engineer whose talents exceeded the job. And one of the reasons for that was he did an apprenticeship at Criteria Studios in Miami as a cutting engineer, because he came from Florida. Now, in those days, cutting engineers had to know how to get a record sounding good on vinyl. That was their job. If you made the snare too big, the cutting engineer would say “why don’t you make the snare a little smaller so you get more bass?” So that balance of sound was in his mind all the time. When we were making the record, he’s thinking, how is this going to sound on vinyl? How is the cutting engineer going to deal with these different frequencies and levels? He was very much designing the record in the back of his mind, as we were being the musicians playing the parts. And it just turned out that we had a certain natural agreement about that. I was throwing things at him that were unexpected, but it was always filtered through his sense of, that’s going to work or it’s not going to work on the record.
Alannah: Alex was so cool. He had been a marine biologist before he had become a record producer. He was a very clever, very laid-back guy. He just got where we were at, at that point. I was playing fire extinguishers, castanets and marimbas and weird instruments. You didn’t have to make an Alex record. You could make whatever you want. He made your record and that was something fantastic.
SDE: And would he have a team of people helping him in the studio?
Tom: It always took us three months to make an album in those days after the writing had been done. I introduced him to Phil Thornalley early on, who was our engineer. He’d worked on a previous album, Set, with Steve Lillywhite. And what happened was we ran out of time at Compass Point on Quick Step&Side Kick, so we said, let’s go back to London and finish it there. We did it at RAK, where Phil Thornalley was the house engineer there at the time, so that became the team.
SDE: Alannah, it was a very male dominated world back then, and I’m sure it probably still is, but what was it like for you, having to navigate that in the early ’80s?
Alannah: The first time I ever went on stage with the old band, which was a load of blokes, was in a pub in Richmond, and I spent ages rehearsing my part, where to come in, where to go out and as soon as I got on stage, these guys in the front just went, “Get your tits out!” And that was how it was. It was really confronting and really crappy. But on the other hand, I found ways around it. I invented hats, I invented a look that was very androgynous and refused to play that game at all. Never did tits and arse. We created cartoon characters. I think the boys did as well.
SDE: This album has really connected with people. Do you think it was what you were alluding to earlier, the emotions in some of the songs alongside the widening of the of the soundscapes?
Tom: That’s what I wanted to do after having experimented with a more purist synth sound. I guess I’ve got a soft spot for the for the wider palette, even the orchestral palette sometimes. But although I never really do that, it pushes in that direction. Just by chance, I happen to be a bit of a multi-instrumentalist, so I play the guitars and the keyboards. It means that I can get on with exploring those production ideas, those arrangement ideas, on my own, rather than having to call people in to do it for me.
SDE: Where did your musical talent come from, Tom?
Tom: I grew up in a family that respected music as a pursuit. My family were all medical and they didn’t like the idea of music as a career. They just thought it was something that a civilised person should do on the side. I think it was a massive disappointment for them, to take it too seriously.
SDE You took it too far!
Tom: Yes! Oddly enough, I was talking to my sister this week, who’s a doctor, but plays in a brass band, and she asked me to write something for her brass band. So we’ve come full circle there. But my father was a great amateur musician, an organist, pianist, and also an early Hi-Fi adopter. He built home Hi-Fi systems. That meant that even as a young child, I was listening to high quality reproductions of music around me. It’s something at the time you can never actually say, “oh, this is impressing me”. It was just part of my world. So it probably had a big effect. I was listening to full frequency, high quality sound, rather than the transistor radio that a lot of my contemporaries would’ve been listening to.
SDE: With your keyboard skills, you must have been delighted with the technological change in the early 80s?
Tom: Absolutely. I’d been fascinated by all that. Watching prog rock heroes that had big synthesizer setups. I couldn’t afford that. But in the early 80s, it became affordable, although even then, it was still the most expensive part of a group’s backline. You could get a guitar for £200 easily, or even less, whereas it was two to three thousand to get the keyboard. So you had to really want it and work for it. But of course, it opened the door to so much creativity. On the last album of the seven piece version of the band, we ran out of songs, and I had just got my hands on a synthesizer. I said I’ll just make a track. It turned out to be the hit of the album, because that night, I managed to pretty much finish ‘In The Name of Love’ at home, which was our first actual international hit. And so that was the writing on the wall for me creatively. I knew I had to pursue working with technology.
SDE: When you went on tour with this record recently as a solo artist, how easy was it to create the sound on stage?
Tom: Back then, it was a new era of using backing tracks alongside a live band, and how to synchronise those things, so it was a big experiment. We had a great live band. I think it was a seven-piece band we toured Into The Gap with. These days, we don’t use backing tapes, we use computers to synchronise all sorts of effects on stage. These things are a big part of the technological revolution. Sometimes it’s nice to get away from it, and in other projects sometimes I insist on no technological support. But everybody these days, and certainly in the pop world, is using technology as far as they can afford to, to make the whole thing brilliant.
SDE: Did you enjoy the touring in the 80s? Some bands love it in the studio – writing and recording the albums – but perhaps slogging around the world for nine months isn’t everyone’s idea of fun. How was it for you?
Alannah: For Into The Gap touring was brilliant. Well, actually, for those first two albums, it was really great. We had a brilliant band. I said I wasn’t going out unless we had women in the band. By then, I had some power to be able to go, “I ain’t going anywhere unless I got some more girls with me”. We got a fabulous keyboard player called Carrie [Booth], who became one of my best friends. And then my makeup artist, she also became one of my best friends and she came out and did wardrobe, because then we had more money to be able to do that then. You know, we had a few women riggers. We had women working in different roles. I purposely and consciously did that, and that worked great. At one point being on tour in America, the whole of the back room of the bus was just women and all the blokes had to be up the front. For me, that was triumph and revenge at the same time!
Tom: There’s the whole dynamic of leaving your family behind when you go on tour. The weird thing was Alannah and I were together in those days, so we weren’t suffering that dislocation. I actually enjoyed touring a lot, and I think Alannah and Joe did too. In the studio, they were kind of hanging around waiting for me to finish, whereas as soon as we got out in the world, they were engaging with people, and getting the adoration and feedback as well, which is part of the psychology of it. The big thing in those days was you lost money on tour in order to promote record sales and you’d make your fortune from records. And these days, it’s entirely the other way around.
SDE: ‘Hold Me Now’ became a hit while you were still recording the Into The Gap album, didn’t it?
Tom: Yes, I’m not quite sure how we came to that decision, but I think it’s because Christmas was coming, and we wanted ‘Hold Me Now’ to be out there. So we thought, if we go to the Bahamas and start recording, it might be three months before we even get anything back to put out. So let’s rush in. I went to RAK in London and recorded ‘Hold Me Now’, without Alex. He turned up at the very end and got me to re-record some of the vocal lines but all the music was done before he arrived, and it just sounded fantastic. So we said, okay, let’s mix that, leave it with the record company and go off and make the rest of the album in the Bahamas.
‘Hold Me Now’ was fanastic. It was a magic moment. Everything just gelled.
Alannah Currie
Alannah: We knew we were onto something with ‘Hold Me Now’. It just worked. It was a magic moment. It was fantastic. Everything just gelled. It just came together. There is very much a thing in songwriting – and the same actually in art making, because I’ve done that for the last 20 years – where there’s a moment where you just know things work. And in a way, you don’t write the song, the song writes you. It was like being in a very dark room, and suddenly you put your fingers through holes in the sky and connect with something that’s so universal. And I do believe it’s magic, and we can all, as artists, make up theories about it, but it’s something really quite wonderful when that happens. And ‘Hold Me Now’ was one of those moments.
Tom: ‘Hold Me Now’ was put out in the UK and internationally, and particularly in America, we started getting these phone calls saying, “it’s going up the chart, it’s really exciting, it’s going to be massive”. I remember these phone calls, because in the Bahamas, you actually had to book time to get a phone call in. We’d all be sitting around the speaker listening to the phone call, and it’d be someone saying, “it’s gone crazy in America”. So that had an interesting effect on us, which was it really excited us to realise that we had to make the album as brilliant as possible. We had a flagship out there doing business for us, to ignore that would have been crazy.
SDE: Did the record company ask to hear demos before you went out to Compass Point to record the album, or did they leave you to it?
Tom: No, I think they only did that on Quick Step and Side Kick, because that was like a new project. By the time we got to Into The Gap, it was our habit to leave London and go on a kind of writing residency. We’d rent a kind of lonely farmhouse, somewhere where it was difficult to go to parties and clubs, so that we would actually just work. And we did that somewhere down in the Romney Marshes [in southeast England]. We had a house, and I remember Alex coming along and listening and he was happy and we were happy.
SDE: So you weren’t coming up with new songs in the studio when you were recording the album?
Tom: Well, I think that some of them were more complete than others. So some of them were bare bones of ideas that we had to flesh out in the studio. I was also getting into the beginnings of programming, which was completely unreliable. I remember going to Compass Point with more or less the whole rhythm section of the album programmed on an Oberheim machine [OB-Xa], on Quick Step this was, and we were hit by a big thunderstorm that night. The studio got struck by lightning and it wiped the memory of everything I’d been working on for weeks, if not months. I had no backup, but in those days I could just remember all the parts anyway, so I did it by hand. So things that had been really kind of rigidly played by a machine I ended up doing by hand. Maybe in a funny kind of way that gave it a kind of human feel. I don’t know. They’re kind of subconscious things you can’t really evaluate. But I often wonder if that was the case.
SDE: We should talk about the Dolby Atmos mix, because David Kosten [who created the mix] told me you went round to his studio and listened to it in all its glory with the multi-speaker up. What did you think of it? And what do you think of immersive audio in general?
Tom: I remember Alannah was kind of suspicious and I was relatively ignorant of the whole format, so I was kind of interested. And it’s a shame to have to say this, but my hearing isn’t what it was. I’m coming up to 71 and I’ve lost a bit of high frequency through age and abuse. So I don’t trust that I could hear all the detail that was being presented by the Dolby Atmos experience. It sounded great to me, but I said I can’t be the one to make the final call on this. You have to be sure that you’re doing the right thing. However, I did notice a couple of things that I thought weren’t right and asked them to be fixed. And so I was really glad to hear it that way.
Alannah: I just got the air pods yesterday and listened to the first part of ‘Hold Me Now’. And that was really lovely. I’m not an audiophile, particularly, but it was amazing.
Tom: To your question about what I think about the format in general. I mean, I’m aware that there aren’t that many people in the world who can actually listen to Dolby Atmos…
SDE: Well, this is the thing. There’s different levels now, in terms of listening to it. Headphones via streaming, full amplifier/speaker set-up with blu-ray audio…
Tom: I’m quite happy for there to be so many different ways of listening to the same piece of music. In fact, part of the Thompson’s legacy, is we made different versions of everything, dub mixes and extended instrumentals. It was part of the mindset that there is no singular way of listening to something. We didn’t even have the phrase post-modern in those days, but it was part of the revolution of deconstructing the singular authorship of anything, and I think that in that sense, it falls directly in that tradition. It’s just a new way of listening to something which is hopefully exciting and entertaining and interesting, and reveals something in the experience that wasn’t available before. So that’s how I see it.
SDE: What your abiding memories when you when you hear the album today. What does it mean to you?
Tom: Listening to anything that I’ve done in the past, for me, is like reading an old diary. It connects you with the past. You remember the people you were hanging out with, the ideas you had, the excitement of it, the stress of it, because it was really, really hard work, and we gave ourselves incredibly difficult goals to achieve. We didn’t fool around too much. We worked really hard. So those are the memories I have. I think there are a couple of albums in my career where everything seemed to just fall into place in that magical way. And Into The Gap was one of them. The other one, oddly enough, was the first Babble album [1994’s The Stone], which is what the Thompson Twins became when when we imploded into an underground band again. I really like the first Babble album, but from the more well-known era, definitely Into The Gap. I can’t see anything wrong with it.
Alannah: It was just extreme madness and a lot of fun! It was so high pressured, but we also had loads of resources available to do whatever we liked and go wherever we wanted. It was also very out of control, the whole thing. You just got on this high-speed train that somehow let you in, and you were on it, and there was no getting off it. You just couldn’t get off it. You just had to ride it and see where it ended. That was it. It was mad. It was totally mental.
SDE: That’s a good analogy. You couldn’t get off the train, just waiting for it to derail at some point?
Alannah: Absolutely, you were praying for a crash. And I think probably that’s what lots of people do in the end. Because we’ve often joked, Tom and I, that it was easier to get a divorce than it was to get out of a band!
SDE: You’ve got all these external pressures, haven’t you?
Alannah: Everybody’s so invested in you being in the band. Everyone, from your sisters and your mothers, because everybody gets prestige out of knowing somebody in a band, to all the people who are on the road with you who have got jobs, to people paying off their mortgages because they’re in your office and they mistakenly think they’ve got a job for life. It’s really hard to get out of, so the pressure is absolutely enormous. And to have to say to all those people “Bye, we’re leaving”, it’s just terrible. You make everybody redundant in every way. We’ve still got sisters and aunts and uncles and people going, “When are you going to reform? When are you going to be on Top of the Pops again?” And you go, oh for god’s sake, give it up! I’ve done it for 30 years. They’re desperate for that stuff, and I get it, but don’t want it.
SDE: So presumably, there’s no chance of the three of you ever getting back together and getting up on stage again?
Alannah: I can’t think of anything worse, to be honest. It was of its time. It was brilliant. But I don’t reflect much, I don’t go back. I still feel like I’m going forward with ideas. And you know, touring was fun for a while, but by end of it, just no, no, no. And Tom and I were married, we were together for 23 years. We have two children now, and grandchildren together. So we’re sort of family, but there were reasons why we divorced. It’d be very hard for us to be in the same room for longer. We have meetings, but we don’t really want to hang around with each other too long.
That was another aspect to our whole band thing: we never had a ‘wife’. If you look at all those pop stars, they all have wives to look after their lives, to look after their children. Tom and I were doing the same thing. We were involved in the same work at the same level and it was very hard to have any sort of cared for life. We were very isolated and on our own. And then once we had children, there was nobody to look after the house and the children, like those other pop stars, it was just us. I don’t think children and being in the music business go together at all. I didn’t want my kids raised in the music business. So for me, it became a choice at the end – quite a determined, clear thing that I wanted to have a family. I prefer that over music.
SDE: Into The Gap was the most commercially successful of your records. But does that mean it’s your favourite?
Tom: I don’t know about favourite, but the arc of our celebrity coincided with our one of our best pieces of work. So in that sense we were lucky. By comparison with the first Babble album, everyone had lost interest in the Thompson Twins, and we were doing great work, but no one was listening to it. Similarly, there were other Thompson Twins albums during our period of celebrity, which weren’t 100 percent brilliant. People were listening to them, but there were some kind of bad patches on there. It doesn’t happen with every album, but with Into The Gap, it happened.
SDE: Is this reissue something of a new start? Now you seem to have a positive relationship with BMG, is there a road map for what’s going to come in the next few years?
Tom: I don’t know. Everyone on their side is doing a good job, and there’s talk of greatest hits sets, there’s talk of a live album that they’ve discovered. There’s talk, inevitably, of Quick Step and Side Kick getting the same treatment. I’m not sure how keen the other two are about it because from their point of view, this is just kind of remonetizing their past and there’s no real creative input for them, whereas for me, it makes total sense, because I’m back in the live business. So, to have albums out that have been promoted by a record company is a massive plus for me and really exciting.
Alannah: We had a really bad record deal previous to signing with BMG, we only signed with BMG a year ago, or not even that, six months ago… eight months ago. I think it took three years to renegotiate a deal with BMG. It was suddenly like they were human beings, cool people again and they suggested putting Into The Gap out. They want to do a live album because they’ve found all these tapes. They hadn’t listened to any of this stuff. Nobody had listened. It has effectively been in the tombs gathering dust, in the basement of whoever’s archives.
Thanks to Tom Bailey and Alannah Currie both of whom spoke to Paul Sinclair for SDE. The Into The Gap 40th anniversary reissue is out now, although sadly the SDE blu-ray audio has sold out.
Bon Jovi’s breakthrough album, 1986’s Slippery When Wet, will be reissued next month across a number of physical formats.
The band’s third studio album, which features the classics ‘Livin’ On A Prayer’, ‘You Give Love A Bad Name’ and ‘Wanted Dead Or Alive’ will be available as a 2CD set, with rare and unreleased bonus tracks, and as a limited edition vinyl picture disc, limited to 1500 copies, via Universal Music/band channels.
The new 2CD set
Highlights on the bonus disc include a new extended mix of ‘Livin’ On A Prayer’ (the ‘Thank You Goodnight Mix’), an acoustic version of ‘Wanted Dead Or Alive’ and some live tracks from the Slippery When Wet tour.
Other formats for this new campaign include a cassette tape and a “liquid disc” vinyl version (limited to 1300 copies). A blu-ray of Slippery When Wet was actually released back in 2015 which featured a 5.1 mix and five promo videos, but there’s no such format this time around. There is actually an Atmos Mix on streaming, although it’s not clear when this emerged.
Slippery When Wet will be reissued on 28 February 2025, via UMR.
The vinyl picture disc can be pre-ordered from the Sound of Vinyl in the UK and in the US.
Franz Ferdinand release only their sixth album. The 11-track long-player has received rather mixed reviews and is produced by Mark Ralph. It also features new drummer Audrey Tait.
Compare prices and pre-order
Franz Ferdinand
The Human Fear - amazon exclusive vinyl picture disc
Ringo’s new country music album is produced and co-written by T Bone Burnett. It was recorded in Nashville and Los Angeles last year and features 11 new songs.
The Church’s fourth album from 1985 features the singles ‘Already Yesterday’, ‘Tantalized’, and ‘Columbus’. This red vinyl edition is expensive because it’s an Australian import.
Neil Young appears to have ‘lost’ more albums than most, and next month he will release another unreleased long-player from his incredible archive.
Recorded in 1977 Oceanside Countryside rather confusingly has the same name as CD 4 in last year’s Archives Vol III but while they are similar, they’re not exactly the same. The versions of the songs ‘Lost in Space’, ‘Captain Kennedy’ and ‘The Old Homestead’ are the versions that ended up on Hawks and Doves (in 1980) while ‘Sail Away’, ‘Goin’ Back’, ‘Human Highway’, ‘It Might Have Been’ and ‘Pocohontas’ are actually the same as on Archives Vol III. ‘Field of Opportunity’ and ‘Dance Dance Dance’ are slightly different to the versions of Archives Vol III, because on these versions Young is on backing vocals, rather than Nicolette Larson.
But NY stresses that “These songs are the original mixes done at the time of the recordings”. The Oceanside element (side one) was recorded in Florida and Malibu with NY singing and playing (most of) the instruments. Countryside (side two) features songs recorded in Nashville with Ben Keith, Joe Osborn and a few others.
Oceanside Countryside is being released as part of Neil’s newish Analog Originals Series (AOS). The 50th anniversary clear vinyl of On The Beach displayed ‘Analog Originals’ on the front, as did box number six in the “Official Release Series” (Discs 26, 27, 28 & 29). It’s a little hard keeping track of all these series, since in the past other ‘lost albums’ (e.g. Hitchhiker) have been issued via the Special Release Series (SRS) banner.
Oceanside Countryside will be issued on vinyl (mastered by Chris Bellman at Bernie Grundman Mastering) on 7 March 2025 (was 14 February) via Reprise Records. A clear vinyl edition is available via selected retailers and a CD version will follow in April.
Still not exactly a massive bargain, but a decent discount on the Queen 1 collector’s edition box set which will probably end up going out of print in the not too distant future! SDE unboxed it, here.
Ludicrously great price for this numbered limited edition of Elton John’sDiamonds: The Ultimate Greatest Hits Collection. This Amazon-exclusive 2CD deluxe is limited to 2,000 units and comes complete with a silver holographic slipcase. This is the 34-track deluxe which starts with Your Song and ends with Circle of Life.
As 2024 draws to a close SDE takes its customary look back at some of the best box sets of the year. What follows are nine boxes, singled out for special praise, but listed in no particularly order, and then at the very end SDE’s overall Box Set of the Year for 2024.
David Bowie: Rock ’n’ Roll Star!(Parlophone)
The David Bowie Estate and Parlophone took years to finally get DB archive releases right. The ‘era’ box sets (which started with Five Years while Bowie was still with us, in 2015) mostly served up audio that fans had already bought many times over and what with the ‘random’ vinyl editions (where you might get black or a coloured vinyl pressing, depending on your luck), the Brilliant Live Adventuresfiasco and putting the brakes on the anniversary seven-inch picture discs before Scary Monsters (with no apology or explanation) there was always a feeling that what fans actually wanted was secondary to what the label (or the Estate) wanted to serve up. The change came in 2019 with the Conversation Piece box (reviewed here), an excellent 5CD set which documented the road to Bowie’s 1969 David Bowie/Space Oddity album. This was followed by Width of a Circle (for The Man Who Sold The World, also reviewed on SDE) and 2022’s Divine Symmetry (Hunky Dory). A bit more like it, even if the label still put out ridiculously overpriced vinyl product at the same time, such as the single LP Mercury Demos box which was £100, the series of seven-inch vinyl boxes that preceded Conversation Piece and a ludicrously overblown approach to the Toy album (6×10-inch box set anyone?). Rock ‘n’ Roll Star! is, in essence, a Ziggy Stardust super deluxe edition. Five CDs and a blu-ray, it’s hard to argue with the content – or the excellent packaging. The only grumble was the decision to omit the brand new Dolby Atmos mix, although that was at least made available separately.
Often, the artist being ‘closely involved’ in a box set or reissue can cast the hand of doom over the project as their own personal tastes and predilections inform what is and isn’t included. For example, they might dislike a certain B-side so it gets omitted, or it turns out that they always despised some remix, so that gets the chop, and/or they simple can’t understand why anyone would want to hear early demos, so they are not considered. Thankfully, none of that was true with February’s alliterative Religion, Revolution & RailwaysDream Academy 7CD set which delivered all manner of delights, including all three studio albums. Nick Laird-Clowes was very hands on and worked closely with mastering engineer Tony Dixon to make sure the sound was exactly how he wanted it to be (no brickwalling here) and personally helped search the Warners archive for unreleased rarities.
Ultravox: Lament (Chrysalis)
Chrysalis have been delivering superb Ultravox box sets on both vinyl and CD for a few years now and this year’s 40th anniversary reissue of 1984’s Lament is arguably their best yet. Beautifully packaged with spot varnishing on virtually every element (respecting the original design), the 7CD+DVD edition delivered almost everything you could possibly want. It included the original 1984 stereo mix, a new Steven Wilson remix, two discs of remixes and rarities, a further CD of brand new extended mixes (many by Steven Wilson) and then two CDs of a live concert from Hammersmith in ’84. On top of that was a DVD with album and B-sides in 5.1 Surround Sound and hi-res stereo. All this with a price tag between £50 and £60 left most SDE readers asking, if Chrysalis can do this, why can’t other labels?
John Lennon: Mind Games (UMR)
The Grammy-nominated £1350 super deluxe of John Lennon’sMind Games was a fantastic art piece but is ruled out of SDE’s best box sets of the year simply because it’s far too expensive to come recommended. However the 6CD + 2 x blu-ray ‘deluxe’ edition was still a superb product, with six kinds of mixes of the album available (Ultimate, Elemental, Elements, Evolution Documentary, Raw Studio and Outtakes) in stereo, 5.1 and Dolby Atmos. 72 tracks in total, with a few hidden tracks to boot (all the audio in the massive box). The book (complete with invisible ink, in places) was amazing and the only thing fans were left to ponder was whether a middling album such as Mind Games was worthy of such treatment, but it’s surely churlish to complain about ‘too much’ content, even if the price tag of these Lennon packages are creeping up.
Thin Lizzy / 1976 (Decca)
Since they were both released in 1976, what are probably Thin Lizzy’s two best albums (Jailbreak and Johnny The Fox) were brought together in this 5CD+blu-ray box set, called simply 1976. With the albums short enough to squeeze onto one CD there’s masses of content with original mixes on CD 1, new stereo mixes on CD 2 and then outtakes for both records on CDs 3 & 4. The CD audio is completed by Live in Cleveland, a radio Broadcast from 1976 and the included blu-ray offered Atmos, 5.1 and both stereo mixes of the two albums. Like the Ultravox Lament set, 1976 was very well priced and you were getting two album’s worth of content, not one. Both Lament and 1976 are now out-of-print, which shows that great box sets, well-priced, do sell!
Rusty Egan presents Blitzed! (Demon Music)
Demon Music are the kings of the themed compilation these days and there were some good ones this year, including Katie Puckrik’s Yacht Rock Odyssesy. That was fantastic but ultimately we preferred Rusty Egan presents Blitzed! Curated by Egan himself, the DJ at London’s celebrated Blitz Club in the late 1970s/early 80s, this goes well beyond the generic 80s compilations and offers a brilliant selection of tracks from the likes of the Tubeway Army, Fad Gadget, Magazine, Iggy Pop, Pretenders, John Foxx, Sparks, Kraftwerk, Japan, Blondie, Visage, The Cure and more. The only negative is the glaring omission of David Bowie songs, due to pesky licensing restrictions.
Lindsey Buckingham / 20th Century Lindsey (Rhino)
The Solo Anthology of 2018 was a real treat but Lindsey Buckingham’s health issues and then the COVID-19 pandemic delayed actual album reissues, remasters of which had been in the can for some time. These finally saw the light of day this year with the 20th Century Lindsey box set, available on vinyl and CD. The three albums included were Law and Order (1981), Go Insane (1984), and Out of the Cradle (1992) and they are all well worth owning. As a bonus disc is included with rare extended mixes and non-album tracks. How Lindsey Buckingham didn’t have enjoy more commercial success as a solo artist remains one of life’s great mysteries.
Retrospective / Bryan Ferry (BMG)
Over the years, Bryan Ferry compilations have mostly also included music from Roxy Music which admittedly makes sense commercially, but creatively meant that toes were only dipped in the shallow waters of Ferry’s solo oeuvre. In its 5CD form, this year’s Retrospective turns all that on it’s head with a deep dive into Bryan’s output starting with tracks from 1973’s These Foolish Things and bringing the story right up to date with a new track, ‘Star’, recorded with Amelia Baratt. The well-structured package starts off with a 20-track ‘best of’ before individual themed discs cover ‘Compositions’, ‘Interpretations’, tracks from the Bryan Ferry Orchestra and so on. The final CD features rarities and the whole thing is a near-perfect appreciation of the songwriter and musician’s 50-year output away from Roxy Music. The one much remarked upon negative was the £130 price point, but whole thing was beautifully presented and a bit of indulgence for Ferry doesn’t seem as foolish as the sigh of midnight trains in empty stations.
Bob Dylan and The Band / The 1974 Live Recordings (Sony)
An unbelievable 417 previously unreleased live performances were included in this Bob Dylan and The Band 27CD box set. This offering is what the compact disc was made for and at around £100 it seemed like an utter bargain. A mix of “every single surviving” soundboard recording and (later in the tour) multi-track recordings, this kind of forensic examination of a tour that used to be the domain of the bootleggers, but is now being officially released by Sony. It’s an amazing time to be a Bob Dylan fan.
Box set of the Year, 2024: The Police / Synchronicity (UMR)
With close to zero meaningful archival activity since The Police’s original albums were released over 40 years ago, fans were starting to give up. Finally, this year a Police long-player got the box set it deserved and the album in question is 1983’s Synchronicity. The content across six CDs was remarkable: a CD which rounded up every B-side, instrumental, edit and live tracks (content which originally peppered the various single releases back in the day); two discs of unreleased recordings including Sting’s original demos recorded in late Autumn 1982; and then a complete unreleased live concert. Fans could be forgiven for thinking they’d died and gone to heaven. At £80, it felt perhaps a tad more expensive than it should have been, although the large format hardcover book was nicely done. Disappointingly, there was close to zero promotion for this set. Having finally opened up his archive, Sting didn’t do any press and the other two musicians – Stewart Copeland and Andy Summers – wouldn’t talk to SDE despite the fact that we’d interviewed them for various personal projects in the past. With no companion Netflix documentary, no Sting on The One Show to talk about the box set (like he often does for his solo projects) the Synchronicity reissue didn’t get the spotlight it deserved. As a result, one suspects the super deluxe edition of rather underperformed, which, if true, is a massive shame. Those that did buy it will undoubtedly treasure it for years to come and hope that the other Police albums will get the same treatment.
We hope you enjoyed our selection. What were yours? Leave a comment below.
Elton John/Diamonds: The Ultimate Greatest Hits CollectionBlu-ray
Elton John’s best-selling, career-spanning compilation is released exclusively on blu-ray via SDE. It features 48 tracks mixed in immersive Dolby Atmos by Greg Penny, along with 51 tracks in hi-res stereo. Shipping this week, we now have some final stock due to cancellations/contingency. Order via the SDE shop.
If immersive audio isn’t your thing, there’s also a new version of the 34-track, 2CD edition of Diamonds, available only via Amazon in the UK, with an exclusive slipcase. This edition is limited to 2,000 units.
In the early 1990s, my friends and I used to always give each other CDs for birthday or Christmas presents. It was seen as a great gift, since everybody I knew loved music and CDs, being relatively new at the time, were seen as a premium item.
Also, we were all young – I was in my early 20s – and were still exploring the classic eras of the 1960s/70s/80s when it came to music, so someone might choose to buy me a Neil Young or Roxy Music album on CD that I simply didn’t know at all at the time and I would be delighted! I didn’t have much money and had only owned a CD player since early 1990, so I actively wanted people to buy me CDs and was disappointed when they didn’t!
Fast forward 30 years and the reputation and perception of the humble CD, as a gift, has been somewhat battered. What sort of a gift is music anyway, these days, for the average Joe, when it’s basically available free via streaming and YouTube? If music is perceived by many as having close to no value these days, then has music become the gift no one wants to receive, or for that matter, to give?
It has been a long time since anyone has bought me music as a present. The general consensus seems to be that it would be a fool’s errand trying to buy Paul Sinclair physical music. “You’ve got everything, already!” appears to the understandable, if inaccurate, consensus. Or it would be impossible to know what to get me (more reasonable, to be fair). It’s sad, in a way, but friends and family possibly also think it would be a bit of a busman’s holiday for me (“the last thing he’s going to want is music!”). This is also not accurate, I still enjoy music as much now as I ever have!
My two daughters are 17 and 22 and they probably have a greater than normal interest in physical music, in part, I guess, because of their dad’s day job and because there’s so much in the house they have access to! The eldest is into K-Pop, a genre known for flashy packaging and multiple editions of the same album, while the younger of the two is massively into Taylor Swift, an musician and songwriter who has perfected the art of selling the same album over and over again, with multiple variants, ‘anthology’ editions and ‘Taylor’s Version’ re-recordings of old albums (which aren’t actually very old, in the scheme of things).
I was in HMV just before Christmas and thought I’d pick up some releases as presents or stocking fillers. American singer and songwriter and new ‘big thing’, Chappell Roan, has become a favourite with my youngest and I knew she didn’t own it physically, so I thought I’d get that. Now I love CDs as much as the next man, but they aren’t much more expensive than they were 30 years ago, which is good if you’re buying for yourself, but not so good if it’s a gift. A compact disc that cost £13 in 1991 should be over £29 in today’s money but they are still around £13 (or less). To put it another way buying a CD for someone today is like spending less than £6 on them in the early 90s. Fine as a stocking filler, I suppose, but if it’s any kind of ‘main’ present you are going to look like a bit of a skinflint.
There is no deluxe CD of Chappell Roan’s debut, The Rise and Fall of a Midwest Princess, despite it now being over a year old, just the standard edition in a card sleeve that was as light as a feather, when I picked it up. It just felt so insubstantial. Labels, probably a little frustrated that consumers won’t pay any more for CDs than they did 30 years ago, have made them as cheap to produce as possible, presumably in order to maintain some kind of reasonable profit margin. So they often come in a flimsy card sleeves, no inner sleeve for the disc, often a thin, minimal booklet. Despite all this, they still sell in large numbers and I’m convinced that frustrated executives at labels, having done nothing to support the format or plan for its future in the last 15 years – quite the opposite, you could argue – must be wondering what they have to do to make, this “inferior sonic storage system” (in the words of Elvis Costello) crawl into a hole and die? You can no longer play them in your car, tick! The mastering is often awful, tick! The packaging is perfunctory, tick! You can get the same content free – or close to free – on streaming, tick! And yet, people (including yours truly) still just like CDs and we continue to buy them.
The vinyl edition of The Rise and Fall of a Midwest Princess sitting next to the CD showed off the artwork beautifully, with a lovely embossed and die-cut outer sleeve, a gatefold package with printed inners and the two records pressed on ‘coke bottle green’ vinyl. To put it bluntly this vinyl edition was going to have a ‘wow’ factor when unwrapped which the CD definitely couldn’t replicate. I’m sure, with this album in particular, the two formats would sound fairly much the same, but because ‘young people’ primarily live in a world of streaming, the physical object has to feel worth owning, otherwise, what’s the point?
The price differential was massive. The 2LP set was £39.99, which on the face of it seems like a rip-off but is actually like spending £17.50 on someone in 1991. A single CD could sometimes edge towards that price, back then, believe it or not. In 2024 the CD of the Chappel Roan album was £13.99 in HMV. So this CD enthusiast ending up buying the vinyl. If I’d been purchasing for myself, I may have gone for the CD but for the reasons explained above, the vinyl seemed like a much nicer present. In fact, HMV had a CD sale upstairs so I did end up picking up various titles as a Christmas present to myself, including albums from The Pretenders, the Liam Gallagher and John Squire record, the ‘Careless Whisper’ CD single and a few others.
CD box sets or deluxe editions in hardcover book packaging and bonus discs still feel like decent packages for gifts but I’ll warrant that a single CD festively wrapped up with a bow on it, as a gift, didn’t change hands much over this holiday period. Or am I wrong? Do you still buy CDs as gifts? Leave a comment and let me know!
I’d like to wish every SDE reader a very Merry Christmas!
2024 has perhaps not been a classic, in terms of reissues and box sets, but here at SDE we have certainly been kept busy, with 18 titles in the SDE Surround Series announced in the last 12 months, with the last five yet to ship (Elton John, The Who, the two Simple Minds albums and Bryan Ferry). Your enthusiasm and passion for this series allows us to continue, so thank you to everyone who placed an order in 2024!
There are exciting plans for more exclusive blu-rays in 2025 and while it will be a tall order to match the level of product we’ve brought to the marketplace in 2024, I’ll do my best. I hope we can get to No 50 in the series next year, which would be an amazing achievement in a relatively short period, but let’s wait and see!
Later this week there will be an SDE review of the best box sets of 2024 and there’s the annual SDE Reissue Preview in the new year, but that aside, I’m looking forward to taking a few days off over this festive period and spend some time with the family and reflect on 2024. I’m sure many of you have had to say goodbye to a loved one this year and I’m no different: a close friend of mine died in early October and I heard yesterday that my sister’s father-in-law passed away on Saturday.
On a more positive note, a new year is an opportunity to turn the page and press ‘reset’. This site has been running since March 2011 and so next year will be SDE’s 14th birthday. Regardless of whenever you discovered this site – whether you are a occasional reader, or a regular; whether you leave messages regularly or are more of a ‘lurker’ in the discussion section – I’d like to say a heartfelt thanks for coming on the journey and I look forward to more adventures next year.
Happy Christmas! I wish you a healthy, prosperous and peaceful 2025.
Fourteen years ago I saw Paul McCartney play a Christmas gig at Hammersmith Odeon and I recall worrying beforehand about whether I’d enjoy the show (spoiler, I did) due to concerns around whether his voice was up to the job of singing all those great songs he wrote and performed with The Beatles, Wings and as a solo artist. I’d been lucky enough to see Macca in early 1990 on what was his Flowers in the Dirt tour and then again a few years later on his Off The Ground-promoting New World Tour, but by 2010 it had been 17 long years since I’d seen Paul up on stage and I had concerns, which turned out to be misplaced.
After that stupendously good show on a very snowy day in West London back in 2010, I thought I probably wouldn’t need to see Paul play again. After all, I’d experienced shows with his old band (Hamish Stuart, Robbie McIntosh et al) and his new band (Rusty Anderson, Brian Ray etc.) and it hardly seemed feasible that in 2024, an 82-year-old Paul McCartney was going to improve on a concert his 68-year-old self did back in 2010. And yet…
Ever since Paul embraced playing The Beatles back catalogue properly in 1989, I think it’s fair to say that no Macca or Fab Four nut – or casual fan – is not going to enjoy a concert. Seeing McCartney play ‘Helter Skelter’, ‘Band on the Run’, the Abbey Road closing medley of ‘Golden Slumbers’ / ‘Carry That Weight’ / ‘The End’, or ‘Live and Let Die’ is never less than an amazing experience, but there are still micro peaks and troughs that exist within this excellence that perhaps the hardcore contingent can reflect on and analyse.
Yes, Paul played 18 or so Beatles songs to a live audience for the first time in 1989/90 and so a splendid time was guaranteed for all, but could you imagine Paul opening a show today with ‘Figure of Eight’, his forgotten fourth single from Flowers in the Dirt, as he did back then? Those shows were also the opposite of drinking Red Bull; they didn’t give you Wings – with just four songs from the bandThe Beatles could have been in what was normally a 33 song set.
Another quirk of the Paul McCartney gig-going experience is the fact that Paul always showed what you could call admirable loyalty to ‘the new album’ – great news when the long-player in question was the good-to-excellent Flowers in the Dirt (1989), not so good for must-try-harder Driving Rain (2001) or Off The Ground (1993). But that’s not the end of the story. This loyalty had a shelf life shorter than fresh cream and Paul had a pattern of dropping songs-from-the-new-album like a super-heated potato for subsequent tours – which had the same impact described above, just in reverse.
For example, in 1989/90 six tracks from Flowers in the Dirt were deemed good enough to displace Beatles, Wings and solo tracks, yet only three years later none of them were included in the New World Tour shows, not even ‘My Brave Face’. I’m convinced if Paul had kept ‘My Brave Face’ in the setlist for every subsequent tour, 25 years later it would be firmly established as the (relative) late period McCartney classic that it is. A halo track in his Costello sessions, all documentary evidence suggests Paul was very proud of this lead single from Flowers in the Dirt, so why doesn’t he ever play it? If I were to hazard a guess I’d say because it wasn’t a big enough hit (peaking at #18 in the UK and #25 in the USA). The showman in Paul wants to please the crowd and deliver a ‘hit-packed’ set and he tends to only make exceptions to this rule to debut new material which, notionally at least, is the reason he’s out on the road in the first place. Old songs that were not big hits occupy an airspace that Paul will not enter. That’s why he doesn’t play ‘The Back Seat of My Car’ from Ram, the title track or ‘I’ve Had Enough’ from London Town or ‘Old Siam, Sir’ from Back to the Egg and others like them. A more recent example of this was the Wingsy ‘Only Mama Knows’ – from 2007’s excellent Memory Almost Full. That song was an album highlight and superb live. Paul really should have kept it in the setlist going forward, but again, it was quietly retired never to be heard live on stage again!
What this means is that while going to see Paul McCartney is always brilliant, it’s a better experience if either he’s just released a pretty good album, or he doesn’t have a specific record to promote and is absolved of the responsibility of playing new songs. This week’s gigs in the UK, the end of his ‘Got Back’ tour, fall into the latter category and on Wednesday night at London’s O2 he played nothing from his most recent album (2020’s McCartney III) and remarkably only three songs recorded in this millennium: ‘Come On To Me’ (from 2018’s Egypt Station), ‘My Valentine’ (from 2012’s Kisses On The Bottom) and ‘Dance Tonight’ (from 2007’s Memory Almost Full).
Freed from the shackles of new album promotion Paul had fun bringing back previous favourites such as ‘A Hard Day’s Night’, ‘Getting Better’, ‘Got To Get You Into My Life’ while making sure not to omit stalwarts such as ‘Live and Let Die’, ‘Band on the Run’, ‘Jet’, ‘Get Back’, ‘Lady Madonna’, ‘Let It Be’, and the like. McCartney seems to have warmed to his Wings back catalogue a bit over the years and while no one can claim he ever plays any deep cuts (‘Morse Moose and the Grey Goose’, anyone?) it was great to hear classic 70s hits such as ‘Junior’s Farm’ (a song he only started playing in 2011), ‘Letting Go’ and ‘Let ‘Em In’, sitting alongside the expected ‘Live and Let Die’ and Band on the Run tracks.
Back to Macca’s voice – it held up well. He’s clearly lost a lot of power but mostly it’s a non-issue with singer and audience more than happy to live with some croaky bits here and there. There’s also a certain poignancy to the effort involved; you’re willing him through some trickier sections; he is 82! His brilliant band with three strong backing vocalists (drummer Abe Laboriel Jr., and aforementioned guitarists Rusty and Brian) give Paul a foundation where he doesn’t have to be perfect, although if I had to select one song that McCartney really should knock on the head it’s ‘Maybe I’m Amazed’. It’s an immensely hard song to sing for someone at the top of their game, and in my opinion it’s just one step to far, for his vocal chords these days. They’ve put in a 65 year shift after all….
The horn section on this tour was a wonderful addition, taking the pressure off the amazing talents of musical director and keyboard player Paul ‘Wix’ Wickens (outside Macca, the only musician common to all three iterations of Paul’s live band since 1989). Despite Wix working wonders on his keyboard rig, real horns on tracks like ‘Lady Madonna’ are always going to sound much better than a synthesised version and there was some fun showmanship in the O2 when, early on, the horn section were not on stage but up high in the crowd; a spotlight picking them up as they played along to ‘Letting Go’.
Big numbers dropped from tours of yonder for Got Back include ‘Penny Lane’, ‘The Long And Winding Road’, ‘Yesterday’, ‘Coming Up’, ‘Eleanor Rigby’ ‘Can’t Buy Me Love’ and ‘Back in the USSR. It has to be said, that Paul continues to disappoint fans of his early 80s output by ignoring singles such as ‘Pipes of Peace’, ‘No More Lonely Nights’, ‘Take It Away’, ‘Tug of War’, and ‘Waterfalls’ none of which he has ever played live! Some artists make a good living out of building tours and set lists around one big hit single (or a number one, if they’re lucky). Such is the embarrassment of riches in Paul’s back catalogue, on Wednesday evening he LEFT OUT at least 20 singles that topped the chart either in the UK or America where he’s credited with writing or co-writing the song (either in The Beatles, in Wings or as a solo artist). That’s insane.
Other reflections on ‘Got Back’ at the O2 was that Paul has upped the ante on production values with his live shows. For ‘Blackbird’ and ‘Here Today’ McCartney plays acoustic guitar alone on an elevated platform and computer animations are projected onto the platform for some powerful moments and there was an amazing animation, that I hadn’t seen before, where Peter Blake’s Sgt. Pepper cover came to life and the famous figures run around in amusing fashion (this run during a rendition of the reprise of the title track).
Paul continues to perform the George Harrison-penned ‘Something’ (from Abbey Road) starting solo on ukelele before transitioning to an excellent full band, live reproduction of the studio recording. Paul tends to let the music do the talking and avoids engaging in any serious storytelling or scene setting when touching on emotional subjects (John, George) or when going back to the very early days of the Fab Four (‘In Spite of All the Danger’, ‘Love Me Do’). The musician tends to limit his chat to “Let’s hear it for George!” type crowd encouragements, which is a reminder that despite being an amazing live performer, all these years and decades later, Paul’s between song banter remains rather awkward and sometimes a bit hackneyed. He’s not a Springsteen-style storyteller, which is not a major revelation – or issue – but sometimes I think it would be good if he said a little bit about the song he’s about to play, beforehand.
One of the most moving parts of the show was Paul’s performance of The Beatles’ 2024 number one, ‘Now and Then’. It’s a sad song anyway, but something about hearing it played live with the video on the big screen was really affecting, as was Paul duetting with John on ‘I’ve Got A Feeling’ (using isolated John vocals sync’d to footage of Lennon from Peter Jackson’s Get Back film).
If you are thinking of going to see Paul McCartney, the simple advice is do it! You will have an amazing time as I am sure everyone did who visited the O2 this week. I could not see one single empty seat in the packed 20,000 capacity arena and while Paul McCartney seems to work miracles by looking great and performing extremely well, it can’t last forever. The man is a national treasure of the highest order and we’ll miss him when he’s gone. Simply incredible.
Paul Sinclair was at the 18 December show at the O2. No, not the one where Ringo turned up…
Tracklisting
Live at London’s O2Paul McCartney/18 December 2024
Steven Wilson‘s 2018 concert film, Home Invasion: In Concert At The Royal Albert Hall, is being issued as a 4K blu-ray early next year.
This concert recording captures the last show of the three-night run in the historic London venue from March this year, as Steven Wilson was coming to the end of his European To The Bone tour.
Four years ago it was issued on various CD, DVD, blu-ray and vinyl formats but now Mercury Studios will put out this 4K release, which requires a 4K compatible blu-ray player and TV.
This new edition will be released on 21 February 2025 via Mercury Studios.
Michael Jackson’s 1979 album Off The Wall will soon be reissued as two new audiophile editions from Mobile Fidelity.
A 2LP Mobile Fidelity UltraDisc ‘One Step’ edition is pressed on 180g vinyl and cut at 45RPM. Audio is sourced from the original master and the vinyl is manufactured at Fidelity Record Pressing. This is limited to 6,000 copies.
The CD edition is a hybrid SACD (stereo-only, of course) and comes packaged in MoFi’s standard mini-LP CD / vinyl replica sleeve.
At £131.99, it’s worth noting that the vinyl is almost £42 more expensive than the Thriller UltraDisc One Step that was offered back in 2022, although Thriller was ‘limited’ to a massive 40,000 copies which is significantly more than Off The Wall this time around.
The 2016 reissue of Off The Wall
MoFi suffered reputational damage back in 2022 when revelations emerged that, despite their claims, they did not always use the original analogue master tapes for their ‘One-Step’ vinyl pressings, and sometimes used digital transfers of said master tapes for some releases. They’ve updated product descriptions and seem to have weathered that particular storm and clearly continue to put out these limited editions.
The last significant reissue of Off The Wall came back in 2016 with CD+DVD and CD+blu-ray sets that paired the original album with a Spike Lee documentary called Michael Jackson’s Journey From Motown To Off The Wall.
This new Mo-Fi Off The Wall will be released on 17 January 2025 and can be pre-ordered in the UK and Europe via the official Michael Jackson shop.